Side-by-side comparison of major reselling platforms
| Feature | 🛒eBay | 👗Poshmark | 📦Mercari | 🌀Depop | 🧶Etsy | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Selling Fee | 12.9% + $0.30 | 20% flat | 10% + 2.9% | 10% + payment | 0-8% | 6.5% + listing |
| Payment Speed | 2-4 days | 3 days after delivery | 3 days after delivery | 3-5 days | Instant (local) | 3 days |
| Audience Size | 182M+ users | 80M+ users | 50M+ users | 30M+ users | 3B+ users | 95M+ buyers |
| Best Categories | Everything | Fashion, shoes | General, home | Vintage, trendy | Local, furniture | Vintage, handmade |
| Shipping | Multiple carriers | USPS only, flat rate | Multiple options | USPS, UPS | Self-managed | Multiple carriers |
| Returns | Buyer favored | Seller protected | 3 day window | Varies | Your policy | Seller sets policy |
| Seller Protection | Money Back Guarantee | Strong | Moderate | Moderate | Limited | Case system |
| Learning Curve | Steep | Easy | Very easy | Easy | Very easy | Moderate |
| Cross-listing | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Manual | Yes |
| Promoted Listings | Yes, 2-15% | Closet tools | Yes, promoted | Boosted listings | Yes, paid | Offsite ads, 15% |
| Offers/Negotiation | Best offer | OTL, bundles | Offers | Messages | Direct message | Messages |
| Sales Tax Handling | Auto-collected | Auto-collected | Auto-collected | Auto-collected | Auto for shipped | Auto-collected |
Best for: Experienced sellers, variety of categories, electronics, collectibles, hard goods
Pros: Massive audience, auction option, multiple shipping carriers, advanced seller tools
Cons: Higher fees, buyer-favored returns, steep learning curve, metric pressure
Best for: Fashion, shoes, accessories, social sellers
Pros: Simple flat fee, strong seller protection, social features, easy shipping
Cons: 20% fee is high, fashion-only, requires daily sharing, USPS only
Best for: Beginners, general items, quick sales
Pros: Low fees, easy to use, flexible shipping, quick setup
Cons: Lower prices expected, smaller audience, less seller protection
Best for: Trendy/vintage fashion, Gen-Z audience, unique items
Pros: Young audience, social/discovery features, cool factor
Cons: Niche market, requires aesthetic, smaller audience
Best for: Local sales, furniture, large items, no-fee sales
Pros: No fees on local, huge audience, easy messaging, quick sales
Cons: Flaky buyers, safety concerns, limited seller protection, lowballers
Best for: Vintage (20+ years), handmade, craft supplies
Pros: Low fees, dedicated vintage/handmade buyers, global reach
Cons: Strict vintage rules, listing fees, offsite ads mandatory